In Bell Trombone Stand

[Driswood]

I used to have an Allsop stand that would collapse and store in the bell while in the case. I remember it being very flimsy and a bad design.
Have these improved over the past 40 years? The only one I have found is the Hercules, but it has 4 points of contact on the floor which I think would be unstable. Does anyone make a stand that has 3 points of contact?
I’m curious if they are any more stable today.

[AtomicClock]

The 4 legs doesn't bother me. I only use it indoors, on floors that are flat. I wouldn't trust it out on a lawn.
K&M makes one. I think it's about as stable as the Hercules.
A new one on the market is from woodwinddesign.com. I've read good reviews, but haven't seen it in person.

[EriKon]

I've seen the woodwinddesign by a colleague at a couple of gigs. It's a great and stable stand. They have some YouTube videos on the stand as well.

I got one myself for my birthday a few days ago. Haven't used it yet but I'm looking forward to use it!

Benefits: storable in the bell/case ; super lightweight ; unbreakable

[SamBTbrn]

https://woodwinddesign.com/product/trombone-stand/

While expensive, if you can afford it, these are great and pay for themselves in how light they are

[dwn8ve]

+1 for the Woodwind Design stands. Been using the bass and tenor ones for a few years and love them

[hyperbolica]

We had a roundup post on inbell stands not that long ago. Try the search if you are interested in more variety. Also does any place actually have the Woodwinddesign stand in stock?

[BGuttman]

I can vouch for the fact that the K&M is terrible. The leg spread is great, but the cone is fragile. I had mine break and I only used it with a Martin Imperial (small bore) trombone.

I've seen the Hercules and it looks nice. Being used with a symphonic tenor with F-attachment. That's an indication that it's pretty strong.

[AtomicClock]

For a while, I thought the K&M had a terrible reputation. Then I realized Bruce just tells his story whenever he can, and I've read one negative review too many times. His broke. Mine hasn't. (Admittedly, I don't use it very much.)

[AtomicClock]

leg spread is great

OF the two, the Hercules wins on this one. I did the math with leg lengths and number (three long legs vs four short ones), and the Hercules has a slightly longer triangle height. But it was close; maybe inconsequential.

[elmsandr]

For a while, I thought the K&M had a terrible reputation. Then I realized Bruce just tells his story whenever he can, and I've read one negative review too many times. His broke. Mine hasn't. (Admittedly, I don't use it very much.)

I mean, it has a terrible reputation because it is a weak and flimsy stand. My hasn’t broken, but I don’t use it for anything larger than a small bore straight horn and I won’t even use it for that out in public if I’m concerned about the horn.

Interested in the woodwind designs stand, but that is a pretty steep price for something that I do not strictly need.

Cheers,
Andy

[BGuttman]

By the way, I'm not the only one with the same problem with the K&M in-bell. Christine Woodcock, posting as RedHotMama reported the same failure before me. If I was the only one with the problem I might not be as strong an advocate against the stand. Note that I have one of their non in-bell stands and like it very much.

[hyperbolica]

I own 4 different inbell stands and don't use any of them in that capacity. They are just not well designed. (My day job is a product designer) either mechanically or in terms of product design / usability. I put my Yamaha practice mute in the bell instead. The Aida stand is light and compact enough to go in my bag.