Richard3rd wrote: Fri Nov 14, 2025 2:34 pm
One of the nice things about the original George Roberts recording is that you hear how he sits on top of the notes. Like many trombone players, you have a tendency to scoop into the note too often and end up a little on the low side. Just something to listen for and be careful of. Otherwise a very, very nice recording.
Here's the original. It's fun going back and forth listening to you both.
I agree with you in some respects, however, if you listen to George's many Youtube recordings in the Coffee shop with his backing tracks, you will notice that he also scoops the notes often, and plays on the low side, maybe it's because we are Trombone players with Slides, I take it by the looks of things, your are possibly a Valve instrument player so No scooping, which would upset me a little, pleased you like my version ( I'm an amateur ) bye the way

) George was Top level as we all know. Please feel free to share any of your own recordings with us.....

Oh and bye the way, the original your posted, It's me
