Page 1 of 1
Shires Q Too Bright to Blend?
Posted: Wed Jul 10, 2019 11:06 am
by tntitan
I’m contemplating getting a Shires Q Tenor, but I’ve read some opinions that say it’s too bright to blend in ensemble work. I play primarily in ensembles so that’s something that concerns me. I’ve been playing a stock Bach 42BO for years on a 5G Megatone mouthpiece. Is this really an issue? Does the Gold Bell option (or a different Shires Custom bell) negate this? Opinions appreciated.
Re: Shires Q Too Bright to Blend?
Posted: Wed Jul 10, 2019 12:32 pm
by Matt K
It's basically the most popular configurations available for Shires so that is unlikely to be the case. Sure, some horns don't jive with certain players so it isn't a guarantee that you'll like the horn or be able to blend with your ensembles but you'd run that 'risk' with any horn. People also told me that about the Xeno I played in college, fwiw. They were right, at least in my hands. And it turns out it wasn't an optimal horn for me, but the pro Yamaha horns are excellent horns and it not being the optimal horn for you isn't a reflection on the horn as much as the player to a pretty large degree, at least in my opinion. The big difference with the Q series is you can swap out components if it doesn't work for you 100% in that setup. There are tons of players on Shires in professional orchestral and wind ensemble settings who blend at an exceptionally high level... so the worst case scenario you have to swap some thing around. That degree of modularity is one of the reasons its higher on the list of horns I recommend if you're buying blind and want new. You can just leave it alone and it's a perfectly fine horn. You can also go down the equipment rabbit hole without too much effort. That's pretty unique in this space.
Re: Shires Q Too Bright to Blend?
Posted: Mon Jul 15, 2019 4:49 pm
by TubaDavey
Blends fine for me against the few other trombones I’ve played with. (Q30, yellow bell, standard rotor.) Great horns!
Re: Shires Q Too Bright to Blend?
Posted: Tue Jul 16, 2019 12:05 pm
by Fridge
I think you’re overthinking this subject. The Q series are great horns. You can get the gold or yellow bell. If want it to play and sound like a Bach, then keep the Bach.
Fridge
Re: Shires Q Too Bright to Blend?
Posted: Tue Jul 16, 2019 12:31 pm
by tbonesullivan
The Q series are very nice. You should not have trouble blending in just about anywhere. If you feel too bright, consider a deeper cup for your mouthpiece.
Re: Shires Q Too Bright to Blend?
Posted: Tue Jul 16, 2019 1:23 pm
by Specialk3700
I think the best thing you can do is play one yourself and find out if it works for you.
Re: Shires Q Too Bright to Blend?
Posted: Tue Jul 16, 2019 9:45 pm
by tntitan
Fridge wrote: ↑Tue Jul 16, 2019 12:05 pm
I think you’re overthinking this subject. The Q series are great horns. You can get the gold or yellow bell. If want it to play and sound like a Bach, then keep the Bach.
Fridge
I am keeping the Bach even if I purchase a Shires. I’m not looking for it to necessarily play like a Bach - I would hope there’s a noticeable difference. But blending in the section is important regardless of which horn I play, and I’m glad to hear/read several comments that endorse the Q in this regard. Thanks